TradeTech Analytics

NSE Nifty 50 weekly options · intraday long CE/PE, opening-range breakout, trailing stop, no target · v1.0.0 · closed 2026-11-04

NIFOPT3 NO EDGE

Owner's breakout + trailing-stop Nifty option buying: reviewed, fixed and tested on 968 sessions. Out of sample 638 trades, expectancy ₹-141 per trade (profit factor 0.65); draft defaults ₹-105; random entries with the same exits do as well. Do not trade live.

Verdict

No edge: do not trade this live

144 of 144 configurations negative net of costs in sample and out of sample. Selected plateau config OOS: 638 trades, ₹-141 per trade, PF 0.65, bootstrap 95% interval ₹-203 to ₹-80; negative even before charges.

  • Data: Dhan 1-minute Nifty weekly options (ATM±10, with OI and volume) and index 1-minute OHLC; 968 sessions 2021-11 to 2025-09, first 60% in sample, last 40% out of sample; sealed 2025-10 onward not opened. Details in bt_out/data_discovery.md.
  • The owner's draft was reviewed and fixed before use: signal exits now fill at the next open, the 15:15 exit at its open, breakout window from 09:30, contracts tracked by strike, dated charges (STT, NSE, SEBI, stamp, GST, IPFT, ₹20 per order). Rules in STRATEGY_NIFOPT3.md.
  • Results (one lot of 65, 0.5 point slippage per side): draft defaults in sample 1018 trades ₹-177 each; out of sample 676 trades ₹-105 each. At slippage 1.0 the selected config loses ₹209 per trade.
  • Random entries with the same exits (100 runs): median ₹-121, 90th percentile ₹-86 against ₹-141 for the rules, so the entry conditions add nothing.
  • Walk-forward (12 months train, 3 months test): all 12 windows negative; 17 of 19 OOS months negative; both sides and every entry hour lose. Only trailing exits (216 trades, +₹674 each) are positive; stops and fail-fast exits cost more.
  • Next ideas (not done): same breakout on index futures, or as a debit spread; range-expansion/regime filters; a real bid/ask sample to calibrate slippage.

Promotion gates

No gates published for this strategy.

Explain the strategy

The breakout rules for buying options lose money in every version we tried, even before costs.

Report

144-configuration grid (sorted by plateau score): in-sample and out-of-sample expectancy per trade

min_extrasl_atrtrail_atrgivebackfail_minitmis_nis_expis_pfis_winoos_noos_expoos_pfoos_totalplateau
44.01.50.3250951-125.8150.6510.425638-141.3130.654-90157.398-141.043
44.01.50.3150947-133.5070.6160.397638-133.5320.663-85193.309-144.222
44.01.50.5250945-134.7380.630.42634-149.3730.632-94702.218-146.035
43.01.50.3150951-141.9230.5850.41640-131.6260.665-84240.753-148.319
44.01.50.5150942-143.1150.5930.394635-147.7670.625-93832.314-148.996
43.01.50.3250955-144.1720.5940.424640-136.9460.659-87645.324-149.028
44.02.50.3250926-141.9320.6120.366602-165.980.602-99920.09-149.171
44.01.50.3251952-146.6240.6180.415632-109.9350.728-69478.669-150.636
44.02.50.3150923-146.5460.5830.338602-159.4470.605-95987.031-152.228
44.01.50.3151948-148.4120.60.397632-106.7270.73-67451.348-152.876
44.02.50.5250922-146.1360.6030.363601-167.640.596-100751.6-153.321
43.01.50.5150948-147.8820.5720.406637-147.2130.624-93774.636-153.737
44.01.50.5251948-152.9850.6040.412629-121.2680.7-76277.508-153.964
43.01.50.5250952-152.5620.5750.419637-153.0210.618-97474.304-154.391
42.01.50.3150959-146.6420.5310.399642-128.7020.652-82626.725-154.487
42.01.50.3250961-149.1220.530.401642-129.1910.653-82940.599-155.867
43.02.50.3150926-149.9590.5660.343602-160.8170.601-96811.606-155.969
44.01.50.5151944-153.7870.5870.394629-116.6960.705-73401.655-156.24
44.02.50.5150919-155.2120.5620.336601-165.2180.589-99295.753-156.547
43.02.50.3250930-155.9730.5690.355603-167.0490.595-100730.414-156.821
43.01.50.3151949-152.130.5850.408633-114.5930.711-72537.29-157.141
43.01.50.3251955-156.4060.5870.42634-115.6630.712-73330.211-157.692
44.02.50.3251918-157.3170.5970.34602-145.6970.649-87709.329-158.748
43.02.50.5150922-156.0390.5530.342601-166.5880.585-100119.246-160.213
42.02.50.3150902-156.1770.5130.277597-148.1210.611-88428.489-160.262
42.01.50.5150956-158.3450.4940.399639-146.1150.602-93367.501-160.519
44.02.50.3151915-159.210.5790.319602-140.10.656-84339.919-160.672
43.01.50.5151945-156.6210.5750.403630-128.9670.674-81249.077-160.705
43.02.50.5250926-159.3950.5620.353602-173.7170.577-104577.822-161.382
43.01.50.5251950-163.3290.5730.415631-131.5940.672-83036.016-161.656
34.01.50.32501030-160.5110.5670.398686-89.2660.777-61236.294-161.815
42.02.50.3250904-158.3730.5140.281598-151.3020.605-90478.304-162.216
42.01.50.5250958-161.3620.4930.4639-146.9970.602-93930.807-162.474
44.02.50.5251914-161.8530.5870.339601-144.1110.652-86610.831-162.523
42.01.50.3151958-161.9870.5330.395635-109.940.709-69812.099-162.553
42.01.50.3251960-161.6930.5380.397636-106.3630.72-67646.612-163.532
43.02.50.3151916-159.4510.5740.326602-146.2620.642-88049.956-163.625
43.02.50.3251921-164.5390.5760.339603-150.7770.636-90918.595-164.248
44.02.50.5151911-166.1880.5610.318601-137.9340.661-82898.21-164.719
34.01.50.52501026-166.8960.5510.397682-97.3580.754-66398.178-164.742
42.02.50.5150898-164.280.490.275596-155.4730.59-92661.833-165.281
42.02.50.5250900-166.8470.4890.279597-158.6460.585-94711.649-167.047
34.01.50.32511036-166.8930.5720.396681-71.440.822-48650.353-167.55
42.02.50.3151904-164.6560.5380.274598-138.3430.645-82729.235-167.594
42.01.50.5151953-168.4750.5150.393632-128.2590.66-81059.595-167.623
33.01.50.32501037-166.2520.5460.399689-81.3090.793-56022.192-167.64
34.01.50.31501024-170.2320.5250.374686-85.6620.781-58764.124-167.883
43.02.50.5151912-166.8260.5550.325601-149.5040.633-89851.718-167.95
34.01.50.52511033-164.4350.5750.401679-80.5850.798-54717.165-168.335
42.02.50.3251906-164.6780.5420.278599-137.3760.649-82288.322-168.427
43.02.50.5251916-170.6550.5610.337602-154.4790.626-92996.215-168.742
42.01.50.5251955-169.3240.5170.396633-126.0290.667-79776.504-169.114
33.01.50.31501029-170.340.520.386689-82.7850.786-57038.762-169.856
34.02.50.32501002-170.4790.5430.341655-117.9160.709-77235.217-170.517
34.01.50.51501020-174.7270.5140.374683-94.2540.758-64375.41-170.587
33.01.50.52501033-171.6870.530.402686-91.8470.763-63007.313-171.329
32.01.50.31501040-167.210.4870.381683-79.3490.786-54195.047-171.451
24.01.50.32501038-167.4470.5530.389691-88.8420.777-61389.991-171.614
42.02.50.5151900-172.7570.5170.273597-143.2910.632-85544.454-172.128
32.01.50.32501042-169.7090.4880.383683-79.5380.786-54324.438-172.202
33.01.50.51501025-173.4080.5120.386686-92.0040.76-63114.617-172.601
42.02.50.5251902-173.5970.5190.277598-143.2850.634-85684.464-172.961
34.01.50.31511027-176.4620.5380.371680-73.9260.814-50269.996-173.12
33.01.50.32511038-172.6420.5550.396683-71.0090.822-48499.202-173.238
24.01.50.52501033-170.9660.5440.389688-96.9930.754-66731.335-173.303
34.01.50.51511024-172.5740.5440.375678-81.7990.792-55460.056-173.391
34.02.50.5250998-173.9790.5380.34654-112.0670.72-73291.691-173.395
24.01.50.52511042-168.9960.5670.393684-83.9030.789-57389.338-174.243
33.01.50.52511035-171.370.5550.4681-79.7280.798-54294.629-174.612
24.01.50.32511045-173.0690.5610.389686-75.3620.812-51698.248-174.808
23.01.50.32501042-173.2310.5320.391693-80.1540.795-55546.872-175.791
34.02.50.3150995-179.2330.5040.317655-116.9480.705-76601.147-175.844
32.01.50.51501037-176.6440.4550.384681-92.2720.747-62837.3-176.174
33.01.50.31511027-180.1950.5270.378681-74.7120.812-50878.852-176.555
34.02.50.3251996-179.7650.5430.326649-118.3920.715-76836.546-176.908
33.01.50.51511024-176.590.5330.38679-82.0630.791-55720.793-177.082
33.02.50.32501008-180.2210.5120.337658-108.5420.727-71420.345-177.126
32.01.50.52501039-179.7590.4540.386681-93.1640.745-63444.883-177.448
24.01.50.31501030-178.0560.510.366692-86.310.779-59726.486-177.909
23.01.50.52501038-176.5740.5220.393690-90.5840.765-62502.648-178.41
33.02.50.3150999-181.6830.4920.323657-109.7370.72-72097.486-178.577
34.02.50.5150991-182.5950.4970.318654-109.130.721-71371.004-178.692
34.02.50.5251993-182.5290.5360.329647-101.3210.752-65554.569-178.776
23.01.50.31501034-177.4610.5060.376694-82.2720.787-57096.463-178.991
32.02.50.3150977-181.7460.4560.259647-102.1410.729-66085.37-179.289
24.01.50.51501026-181.1470.5020.366689-94.6830.755-65236.566-179.32
33.02.50.52501004-183.450.5060.338657-102.8590.738-67578.278-179.582
32.01.50.32511042-181.5180.4990.384677-72.8230.811-49300.924-179.695
24.02.50.32501008-178.0160.5270.334658-116.4120.711-76599.091-179.707
32.02.50.3250979-184.3420.4580.263648-104.7890.724-67903.459-180.181
23.01.50.32511045-178.8980.5440.389686-72.3180.818-49609.956-180.283
24.01.50.51511031-178.5960.5320.368683-84.4090.785-57651.633-180.39
23.01.50.52511042-175.6880.5480.393684-80.5470.795-55094.452-180.447
32.01.50.31511038-182.2910.4930.378676-77.3630.799-52297.154-180.593
33.02.50.5150995-182.1070.4930.326656-102.6830.734-67360.137-180.893
22.01.50.31501045-177.030.4670.369688-79.3260.785-54576.235-180.924
23.01.50.51501030-180.0240.4990.377691-91.2750.76-63071.112-180.935
24.01.50.31511034-182.6150.5260.364685-77.1350.805-52837.296-181.249
22.01.50.32501047-179.7010.4670.372688-79.5140.786-54705.625-181.567
24.02.50.52501003-181.0950.5230.333657-110.6020.721-72665.546-181.987
32.02.50.5150974-182.5250.4510.262646-97.1030.738-62728.396-182.039
34.02.50.3151988-187.580.5140.302649-120.0050.708-77883.054-182.284
32.01.50.52511039-186.0170.4830.388676-88.3550.769-59727.901-182.751
33.02.50.3251998-184.9640.5280.328650-117.5450.716-76404.308-182.883
32.01.50.51511035-185.8530.4790.382675-91.820.76-61978.389-183.067
32.02.50.5250976-185.4760.4510.265647-100.0410.732-64726.749-183.475
24.02.50.32511002-185.7380.5320.321655-125.7830.697-82387.818-184.108
34.02.50.5151985-189.9560.5070.306647-102.1010.748-66059.311-184.154
23.01.50.51511030-182.0570.5230.372683-83.6990.786-57166.302-184.311
22.01.50.51501042-185.6440.4360.373686-92.550.745-63489.096-184.552
23.01.50.31511033-186.1110.5160.37685-76.9340.805-52700.084-184.647
23.02.50.32501013-186.7680.4980.331660-106.0890.731-70018.752-184.826
33.02.50.5251995-189.7450.5170.329648-99.8850.754-64725.408-185.038
24.02.50.5251999-187.9490.5260.324654-110.7580.729-72436.051-185.392
22.01.50.52501044-188.9310.4360.375686-93.4350.743-64096.679-185.491
24.02.50.3150999-188.4080.4830.31658-116.130.706-76413.735-185.564
33.02.50.3151988-192.230.5040.308649-119.6920.709-77679.907-185.803
32.02.50.3251978-191.4520.4820.265644-116.1660.709-74811.139-186.614
23.02.50.52501009-190.1770.4920.331659-100.4350.741-66186.666-187.057
23.02.50.31501004-189.6790.4740.316660-107.7280.723-71100.49-187.493
33.02.50.5151985-195.0670.4960.31647-101.3440.749-65569.372-187.543
24.02.50.5150995-191.7240.4770.312657-108.3620.722-71193.573-187.554
32.02.50.3151975-193.4540.4750.259644-118.9710.702-76617.025-187.586
22.02.50.3150980-187.1780.4460.255651-101.0230.731-65766.002-187.935
22.01.50.32511050-192.2390.480.374682-74.5230.805-50824.657-188.504
22.02.50.3250983-190.1290.4470.258652-103.6570.726-67584.091-188.612
22.01.50.31511046-192.240.4750.368681-78.9460.794-53761.997-189.261
32.02.50.5251976-192.8720.4750.269642-103.5530.737-66480.719-189.395
23.02.50.51501000-191.1640.4730.318659-100.7180.737-66373.121-189.395
23.02.50.32511002-190.3850.5190.321655-122.4460.702-80202.166-189.835
32.02.50.5151973-194.3030.470.264642-105.4610.732-67705.682-189.86
22.02.50.5150977-189.230.4370.258650-96.3050.738-62598.431-190.046
24.02.50.3151992-193.8320.5010.296655-126.6470.691-82953.73-190.36
22.01.50.52511047-195.2990.4660.379681-89.2940.765-60809.28-190.605
22.01.50.51511043-194.3620.4640.373680-92.6480.756-63000.877-191.072
22.02.50.5250980-192.5320.4370.261651-99.2270.732-64596.785-191.168
24.02.50.5151989-196.7440.4930.3654-110.7950.726-72460.198-191.408
23.02.50.5251999-194.6920.5090.322654-106.810.736-69853.477-191.424
23.02.50.3151991-197.60.4930.301655-125.8030.693-82401.167-193.931
23.02.50.5151988-201.0580.4840.303654-109.5120.729-71620.842-195.054
22.02.50.3251983-199.6360.4690.258650-118.9910.7-77344.438-195.157
22.02.50.3151979-200.5550.4630.253650-121.6790.693-79091.434-196.102
22.02.50.5251981-201.6990.460.263649-108.5560.722-70452.643-196.969
22.02.50.5151977-202.0520.4560.258649-110.3520.717-71618.715-197.608

Rules and parameters

Rules

  1. Breakout of the 09:15-09:29 range and prior 20-bar high/low, body/range ≥0.5, 5- and 15-minute close beyond EMA20 with EMA slope
  2. ≥3 of 4 confirmers: spot vs VWAP, 5-min RSI band, ATM±2 OI shift, option premium rising
  3. Entries 09:30-14:30, expiry day skipped, premium ≥20, cooldown 10 min, ≤3 trades, stop after 2 losses or ₹1,500
  4. Initial stop clip(3×ATR14, 3, 10) points; breakeven at +1R; trail peak − max(2×ATR, 40% of open profit); no target
  5. Fail-fast at 20 minutes below 0.5R; VWAP-against exit before +1R; 60-minute cap; 15:15 hard exit

Parameters

capital
1 lot of 65 (₹ P&L); points also reported
periods
in sample 2021-11 to 2024-03, out of sample 2024-03 to 2025-09, sealed 2025-10 onward not opened
costs
dated Dhan-style charges (estimates), slippage 0.5 and 1.0 point per side
data
Dhan expired options 1-minute + index 1-minute OHLC
pre-registration
research/nifopt3/STRATEGY_NIFOPT3.md
code
research/nifopt3/ (prep, bt, run_bt, analyze)

Instrument

Nifty weekly options, ATM or 1 ITM, one lot of 65 · capital ₹100,000

Known limitations

Logs and raw data

Downloads appear once a data window is loaded.

Files are plain CSV so results can be re-computed independently. Trade dates are IST sessions; returns are net of modelled costs and slippage.